Susan, at Algus Greenspon, is Mathew Cerletty’s fifth solo show in NYC, and his first since 2007. From a heterogeneous history of technically proficient illustration, curious gender-bending portraits, and hollow text paintings, Susan delivers the photogenic Mathew Cerletty as a cool, judicious photorealist primarily interested in examining devitalized interiors.

Mathew Cerletty at the opening of "Susan," November 5th, 2011
Quiet Grace is an exquisite, forensic study of light dispersion and perspective. White daylight beams through illusionistically flat glass panes and mingles with the fresh paint drying on the walls; streaks appear on the adjoining jamb, as if the paint there is still half dry. Light merges with paint, both in the picture and on the surface. Quiet Grace is like Cerletty’s Red Studio. Incidentally, red is the only hue that does not explicitly appear in this painting.

Mathew Cerletty, "Quiet Grace," 2011
Daylight (impossible without its long, red wavelength) washes across the crinkled drop cloth; base shadows articulate these creases, making them appear as cracks in the floor or roots growing from beneath the wood bureau. Cracks, roots, or wrinkles: either way, this is the only expanse of space that isn’t smooth and flat.

Matisse, "The Red Studio," 1911 (Looking at it now, I realize Maurizio Cattelan's "All" is more Red Studio than Cerletty's "Quiet Grace."
On the other hand, we have something defiantly flat, as flat as the glass windows behind it. The electric blue sweater draped over a glossy black chair succumbs to gravity but otherwise refuses material dynamics. Nestled somewhere on its surface are two paint sample swatches. Their horizontal slabs echo the slats on the chair and the ladder. The shiny ladder reflects the luminous walls around it, peach-colored, like the sides of brick buildings during a summer sunset. The ladder’s feet – safety orange – seem to match the orange on the paint roller to its right. Lids of the paint cans reflect the light in the glass panes, as well as some details that don’t appear elsewhere. The lone drawer in the bureau extends forward, as if satisfying a viewer’s urge to tug on the tromple l’oeil knob handles. Steered by Cerletty’s pictorial engineering, a viewer’s gaze ricochets around the painting, like a particle of orange light.

Ring Bearer
Cerletty commits again to primary color interactions in Untitled, which seems to reprise Winkie’s, a 2010 painting included in a group show curated by Timothy Hull and Lumi Tan at Klaus von Nichtssagend Gallery last summer. It also reminds me of his mostly faithful yet marginally expansive reproduction of Wire’s 154 album cover (now relegated to fashion boutique commonplace).

Mathew Cerletty, "Winkie's," 2010
In Untitled, Cerletty populates the black discs of Winkie’s with images that seem to represent 19th century Orientalist scenes. If that’s his goal, then maybe the wavy appendage – here, a coatrack – stands in for the winding python in Jean-Leon Gerome’s flagship painting of this genre, The Snake Charmer. In any case, the black discs serve as windows to the other side of the world, even if that world is just a picture. Untameable fissures agitate the dusty terrain in these outdoor spaces, not unlike the wrinkled drop cloth in Quiet Grace.

Mathew Cerletty, "Untitled," 2011
The most delightfully strange painting here is Ikea, in which the vertical thrust is reanimated by an upwardly expanding triangular burst. Our eyes climb up alongside a narrow cabinet that is so slim that it seems useless, and then meet a fork where the two daisies diverge in their translucent vase. This diverging trajectory culminates in the horizontal, segmented capstone – an image of a key. Meanwhile, the cabinet supports two lazily leaning golf clubs and a stamped, but unaddressed envelope. Is it the palette that makes me queasy? Is it the compressed clutter? Is it the sterile leisure of this sliver of interior decoration? Is it being reminded about the dissolution of the American middle class? Here, there’s no hole in the bucket, but there is a fly in the ointment.
Listen: Wire – I Am the Fly